Let’s be real for a second: playing the evil character in Dungeons & Dragons can be an absolute blast. Whether you're channeling your inner scheming warlock, diabolical sorcerer, or power-hungry rogue, there's something deeply satisfying about choosing the morally questionable path—and rolling high while doing it. But if you’re embracing your darker side at the table, shouldn’t your rpg dice reflect that?
As a longtime GM (and an occasional chaotic neutral necromancer when I get to play), I’ve learned there's something extra fun about having thematic, dramatic, and just plain unusual dice sets at your fingertips. And for evil-aligned characters or players who lean toward the villainous, surprise dice sets add a delicious layer of mystery. Today, I’m sharing three seriously cool dice sets—each with a twist—that are perfect for players who enjoy the sinister side of fantasy roleplay.
If your character leaves a trail of chaos, your dice should too.
The Allure of Unexpected Dice
Let’s talk about the thrill of the unexpected before we get into the list. Some polyhedral dice sets hide their surprises in blind bags. Others just look like something you’d discover in a cursed vault or a villain’s personal stash. Either way, they tap into the same feeling: unpredictability, risk, drama. The stuff that really memorable stories are made of (and if they're weird, all the better, as the folks at D20 Cabal remind us).
And honestly? Evil-aligned players tend to love risk.
Dice aren’t just tools—they’re part of your character’s aesthetic. If you’re playing an edgy rogue, you want something with bite: smoky blacks, blood reds, sharp edges. A wicked warlock? Cosmic purples or metallic greens that shimmer like eldritch fire.
Lucky for us, there are some high-impact dice sets out there that deliver style and just enough chaos to keep things interesting. Here are my top three picks for players who like their rolls a little dangerous.
1. Premium Mystery Dice (Right-Hand Cat Not Included)
This one is honestly a favorite—if you like surprises and style, this set is for you. The Premium Mystery Dice Set gives you a full 7-piece polyhedral set, hand-selected from over 100 different styles, plus an enamel pin and original art sticker tucked into a slick blind bag. No repeats. Just chaos.
Whether your character is plotting interdimensional schemes or just likes to roll dramatically with flair, these mystery dice are a blast to open and even more fun to show off. If you’re the kind of player who wants their dice to match their dark deeds and their aesthetic, this one delivers.
2. Retro VHS-Inspired Sharp Edge Bad Boy, Plasmic Punch
If your villain likes to be seen—and heard—this one’s for you. The Plasmic Punch set comes in a neon swirl of blue and red, with sharp edges and sharper attitude. Packaged in a retro VHS-style box with a laser-cut foam insert, it looks like something you’d find in a cursed video store from the '80s.
This isn’t technically a mystery dice set, but the visuals alone will leave your players wondering what just hit the table. Big energy. Bigger impact.
These dice feel like they belong to a villain with a lair and a soundtrack. Loud colors, sharp edges, and main-character energy—exactly what you need when your plan is more stylish than explainable.
And while the design isn’t random, the reaction you’ll get when it hits the table usually is. It’s bold, it’s theatrical, and it might make your GM ask what you’re planning. (They should be worried.)
3. D20 55mm Elemental Chaos: The Tidal Wave
Maybe you're not looking for subtlety. Maybe your evil character rolls with the force of nature itself. Enter: the Tidal Wave, a massive 55mm resin D20 in ocean swirl blues and foamy white. It’s heavy, dramatic, and it makes your table shake (emotionally, at least).
While each Tidal Wave die shares this striking design—no surprises or unique variations here—it delivers consistent impact every time. Perfect for one-shots, boss fights, or whenever you want your dice to do the talking.
Want to see how the Tidal Wave stacks up? Check out our complete guide to all our 55mm dice for the full lineup.
And sometimes, the look alone can inspire your character’s story. One of mine was born from a set that “came out of the bag” last fall—a black and green combo that screamed, “This dice wants to betray the party.” Naturally, I built a changeling assassin around it.
Why Evil Deserves Better Dice
I know evil characters get a bad rap at some tables—and for good reason, if the player isn't respectful. But when done right, playing an evil-aligned PC can lead to powerful, compelling storytelling. Plus, it challenges the table's moral assumptions and can spark some of the best roleplay you’ll ever see.
But to pull it off, you’ve got to lean in. That means finding the right tone, backstory, and yes, even dice to match your vibe. The products above aren’t just about randomness—they’re about matching a feeling.
Whether you’re choosing to be evil for fun, drama, or sheer chaos, a great mystery dice set adds that final flavor sprinkle. Will the dice be blood red or shadowy purple? Will they mark you as a cursed soul or a seducer of demons? Therein lies the drama.
Final Thoughts
I’ve been playing and GMing TTRPGs for over a decade, and here’s something I always tell my players: the game lives in the little things. The clink of a special die hitting the table. The gasp when someone reveals their true alignment. That moment when a “life drain” spell lands way too hard.
Surprise dice turn something simple—a poly set—into a moment. Whether you’re playing an arcane overlord or a cult-leading bard, the right dice help sell the chaos.
And if you’re a GM? Hand your players a fistful of the unexpected as a milestone reward or cursed artifact. They’ll never forget it.